polished to death

I was walking around Old Town Valencia the other day, looking at the different restaurants and cafes as I passed (always good to keep up with what’s popping up, ya know), and I stopped at one that was clearly going for nice, chic, upscale.
Except every single sign out the front was clearly AI. Overly prettified, the classic ‘enter data, add in whatever you associate with the brand’ job... and then printed out and stuck up.
And instead of ‘ooh, fancy’, I curled my upper lip and side-eyed the establishment.
Walking off my thoughts were… where are we going with this? Are we trying to make everything look the same? Sound the same? Because that’s exactly where we’re headed if we keep at this.
Why does AI content all look the same?
Basically, because it’s all coming out of the same handful of tools, trained on the same stuff, prompted by people asking for essentially the same thing.
There’s a study in Science Advances where writers got story ideas from AI. The stories came out rated as more creative and better written... and also 10.7% more similar to each other. So everyone got a bit better and, well, a shit ton more alike.
It’s giving Stepford Wives energy.
Everything’s perfect, everyone’s smiling, I wouldn’t be able to tell one from a line up, and everything feels just a bit off.
And before anyone @’s me, yeah, I use AI. Mostly for admin, and for arguing with it when it sounds like a LinkedIn bro (which is... often). But over the last few months, that’s what’s pushed me to do more writing, and get back to my own version of creative.
Do customers care if your marketing is made with AI?
You tell me. How many “I came across your profile and was really impressed by...” emails did you bin this week without finishing the first line?
Your buyers are doing the exact same thing.
A Klaviyo survey of 8,000 people found 31% trust a brand less when they can see its marketing was made with AI. Only 7% trust it more. (That’s consumers, and it’s a vendor’s survey, but I’d solidly bet your buyers aren’t any less allergic.)
Polish used to mean someone put the effort in.
Now it mostly means a tool did (with someone on the team fighting with it to sound more human if you’re lucky). So when your proposal, your follow-up email or your shiny new homepage sounds, feels, and looks like everyone in your industry, it gets the same two-second treatment as the slop.
👇
-
Most brand values are 'fluff', in this episode of The Art of Positioning Podcast Brandon Gano COO at Human Ops Technologies, and Emma Berry, a seasoned business coach came together with Beatrice to push back.
They talk about integrating brand values, aligning team efforts with the business direction, and troubleshooting day-to-day operations where implementation has gone wrong, and how it can be done right.
'Operations: Troubleshooting for Business Growth' is available to listen across platforms - listen here.
-
What does a ‘gritty’ business actually look like?
Grit is the rough edge that could only have come from you and your team. Your values, living an breathing - more than the elements of what make up a good human/company.
Who Gives A Crap is one of my favorites here. Back in 2012, to launch a toilet paper company, their co-founder sat on a toilet for 50 hours and refused to get up until they’d raised their first $50,000. It got ‘em their first 1,000 customers. Their UK arm alone did £45.5m in sales in 2024.
Now, try getting AI to come up with ‘sit on the loo for two days’.
Closer to home, I worked with a project management consultancy where the owner’s other life is rock music, and they had brought elements to that in their approach already (sanded down), we put the two together.
So, in a category full of Gantt charts and “circling back”, they turned up with rock energy, and their sales cycles stopped running 40% longer than the industry average.
And it doesn’t have to be a stunt. That’s what they showed because what we found had already existed.
It’s taking a value and exaggerating the heck outta it. Say one of yours is ‘we have fun’. Okay... what does that actually look like? An unhinged email signature competition, where the best one each month wins a prize and you share along publicly? (This is even better if your company deals in emails or messages.) Now people can see the value, and they can tell you walk the talk.
A value you can’t show is just a word on the website - I chatted more about pulling out actual values in this issue.
For me it’s defiance. There are enough templates and ‘shoulds’ out there, and I’d rather refuse the standard answer, even when the standard answer would do the job ‘fine’, along with every other ‘fine’. Which is why, whatever the episode, every podcast I did ended on the same question: what should we be pushing back on?
What does all that polish cost you?
Your buyers bin it like slop. If it looks like AI, it gets treated like AI.
You blend into the shortlist even more. Buyers were already struggling to tell you apart, and the smoother you get, the harder it gets.
Your 2027 ‘refresh’ budget goes on making you shinier and easier to forget. An expensive way to disappear.
Your team can only sell what they can see. If the business looks and sounds AI-smooth, so does their pitch.
Someone else gets there first. The more slop there is out there, the more the obviously-human business in your industry stands out. And it’s going to be somebody.
-
AI-fication is on par with rebrands. Inc. Magazine ran a piece where we spoke about avoiding that thin spread. When a rebrand is the answer, and when it's lipstick on a pig.
-
How do you make a business look less polished without looking unprofessional?
You don’t need to rough everything up. This is about honing down on your edge, so you can stop sanding it off.
That’s what we do. We go through your competitors and your market, find the one thing you do that they can’t follow, and turn it into a 90-day plan for where it shows up, in how you sell, market, hire and decide.
So, how do you take this and roll?
🏏 Badass tip
Pick one of your values. Sit down with the team and ask: what’s the most ridiculous, exaggerated version of this we’d actually be willing to do?
Get a list going, the sillier the better. It’s a fun conversation of imaginations, and you’ll learn a lot about who on the team actually gets what you stand for.
Then pick one and do it publicly before the end of the year.
If nobody can come up with a single exaggerated version of that value... that’s your answer; that value is decoration and doing jack shit for you.
🦘 B
